NY Spring 2009 Contemporary Art Auctions

So the latest trendy phrases are “good works are selling for fair market price” and “people are in observational mode”. Both heard at the contemporary art auctions this week.
Artinfo labeled Sotheby’s sales “solid but uninspiring”, with just over $47million in sales resulting in 81% of lots offered and 78% of the pre-sales dollar estimates. 48 lots were offered compared to 83 lots a year ago and $362million and the lowest result Sotheby’s achieved in a contemporary art sale since 2003.
However an Alexander Calder sculpture sold for $3.5 million which was more than double its estimate.
Bloomberg spotted Actor Owen Wilson billionaire Eli Broad and former Hollywood agent Michale Orvitz at the sale. Larry Gagosian was also there and successfully bid for Jeff Koons’ “Baroque Egg with Bow (Turquoise/Magenta)” at $5,458,500.
Christie’s on the other hand did better and according to Artinfo “charged to a sizzling $93,734,500 tally, reassuringly nestled between pre-sale expectations of $71.5 million and $104.5 million” achieving a “sizzling” 91% of lots offered and 94% of pre-sales estimates. 54 lots were offered compared to 57 at last year’s May sales which brought in $348.2 million. This sale was the lowest contemporary result since November 2004 for Christies.
The highest bid went for the David Hockney portrait of Betty Freeman called “Beverly Hills Housewife,” which sold for an artist record $7.9 million.
Bloomberg spotted Hedge-fund manager Steven Cohen and tennis great John McEnroe at the event. Larry Gagosian was also there and bid successfully with a record price for Roy Lichtenstein’s “Frolic”
The New York Times suggested that Christies did better because of their strategy of conservative estimates and a wider variety of artists appealing to a wider range of collectors. They suggest that the winning of Betty Freeman’s estate which included an excellent contemporary art collection was also key.
Phillips did the worst with Artinfo suggesting that it “limp(ed) to the finish line” with only 72% of lots offered, sold and 57% of pre-sale estimate value.
Anecdotal feedback from the Affordable Art Fair also suggested similar results with only half the number of sales compared to last year.
N.B. I’m sure everybody already knows that estimates do not reflect commissions, which are 25 percent of the hammer price up to $50,000, 20 percent of the price from $50,001 to $1 million, and 12 percent above $1 million for all three companies.

